ActiScore

Agencies

Should an Agency Offer Good, Better and Best Packages?

Randy Hall, CEO— AI-assisted and reviewed prior to publication.

Photo for: Should an Agency Offer Good, Better and Best Packages?

Yes. Three tiers maximize revenue by making the middle option appear reasonable through anchoring, giving clients decision control without overwhelming choice, and creating clear upgrade paths. The structure works only when your Good tier protects profitability, your Better tier holds your target price and scope, and your Best tier is expensive enough to make Better look smart.

How does anchoring actually work in agency pricing?

Anchoring is the underlying effect, where a nearby number becomes the reference point for judging a price. The premium tier exists primarily to make your middle tier look reasonable by comparison. Premium tiers should be genuinely expensive, that's what makes middle tiers appear reasonably priced (ahmmedauthororiginalpricing.medium.com).

When pricing your tiers, the research shows that Good should typically sit at 40-60% of Better, while Best should be priced at 2-2.5 times Better. Price Good at roughly 40% of Better, and Best at 2-2.5 times of Better (miriamodabe1.substack.com). That spacing ensures each tier serves its psychological purpose without the gaps feeling arbitrary.

The BenchPress report by The Wow Company found that agencies that offer three rate options were twice as likely to have conversion rates above 60% (swydo.com). The structure works because customers typically avoid the Best tier because they fear overpaying, they avoid the Good tier because they fear under-buying and missing something important, and the Better tier comes in as the next best thing.

What belongs in each tier?

Build your tiers backward. Start with Better, your ideal engagement at your target price and scope. This package should take into account a combination of what's ideal for your business and your client, charged at exactly what you want to earn for providing the best blend of your services (agencymanagementinstitute.com).

The Good tier contains your core deliverables with no extras. For an SEO agency, that might be keyword research and on-page optimization. For a marketing agency, basic blog posts and monthly reporting. It's not designed to pull in big numbers or be your primary revenue driver, it's designed to protect your time while still offering something at a price you're happy with (futurefirm.co).

Better adds the fence attributes that differentiate you: strategy calls, competitor monitoring, bi-weekly reporting instead of monthly. The middle tier needs something your ICP values enough that the price difference from starter feels like a no-brainer (noslides.substack.com).

Best includes everything plus direct access, weekly reporting, dedicated support, or the services you can deliver profitably at scale only for clients paying premium rates. This tier should include services that justify its price while remaining operationally feasible when someone actually buys it.

Why does the cheap tier often eat the middle one?

When that happens the starter package cannibalizes the middle tier, which is where most of your ICP was expected to buy. This occurs when Good is too generous relative to Better. Either the Good tier is too generous or the Better tier does not add enough felt value.

The fix is creating clear value separation. A leaner starter tier makes the middle look more substantial, and a more expensive enterprise tier makes the middle look more affordable. Never cripple Good to the point it becomes unattractive, but withhold the specific capabilities your target buyers need most. If you are running the free AI-visibility check (/check) on prospect sites and finding gaps in AEO or local SEO, those become Better-tier features, not Good-tier inclusions.

The spacing test is simple: if someone choosing Good can accomplish the same outcome at roughly the same timeline as someone choosing Better, your tiers are not differentiated. Better should deliver measurably different results, not just more of the same activity.

Should you let prospects pick, or prescribe a tier based on their audit?

Prescribe. Research shows the prescriptive sales approach increases purchase ease by 86%, where the sales professional offers a clear recommendation for action to customers backed by a specific rationale.

Research from CEB (now part of Gartner) shows that a prescriptive, proactive selling style (one in which the salesperson presents a clear recommendation rather than an open menu) substantially increases what they term "purchasing ease." Customers who undergo a prescriptive sales process experience less sales regret and are more likely to repurchase, compared to conventional sales methods.

Run the audit, identify specific gaps (DMARC missing, mobile performance scoring below 70, zero AI visibility in Perplexity), then recommend the tier that fixes those gaps. If their site scores 43/100 and competitors average 68, that data justifies Better. If they have no SPF record and their TLS certificate expires in 14 days, that belongs in a different conversation entirely, but the recommendation still comes from you.

When you present pricing to a prospect, lead with the tier the audit supports. Cover the starter quickly ("here's what you'd be giving up"), spend most of the time on the middle tier ("here's what you actually need") and then mention enterprise almost as an aside ("here's what's available if you outgrow this"). You can find full details in the guide (/guide).

The audit becomes the rationale. You are not selling packages, you are prescribing the fix their site needs based on what you measured. That shifts the conversation from "which tier do you want" to "here is what we found and here is what fixes it." The tier structure still gives them decision control, but your recommendation removes the friction of choosing blind.

For agencies white-labeling audits at scale, this matters operationally. You can deliver hundreds of scans monthly on the Growth plan at $199 through ActiScore's pricing (/pricing), score prospects automatically, and use that scoring to prescribe tier fit before the sales call even happens. The structure scales only when the recommendation precedes the menu.

Common questions

How should I price good, better and best tiers?

Price your Good tier at roughly 40-60% of your Better tier, and your Best tier at 2-2.5 times your Better price. This spacing ensures each tier serves its psychological purpose, with the premium tier making your middle option appear reasonably priced through anchoring. The Better tier should hold your target price and scope, while Good protects profitability and Best creates an expensive comparison point that makes Better look smart.

What should go in each pricing tier?

Build your tiers backward starting with Better, which should contain your ideal engagement at your target price and scope. Good contains only core deliverables with no extras to protect your time while remaining profitable. Better adds the differentiating features your ideal customer profile values most, like strategy calls or enhanced reporting. Best includes everything plus premium services like direct access, weekly reporting, or dedicated support that you can deliver profitably only at premium rates.

Why is my cheap tier cannibalizing the middle one?

Your starter package cannibalizes the middle tier when Good is too generous relative to Better, or when Better does not add enough perceived value. This happens when someone choosing Good can accomplish the same outcome at roughly the same timeline as someone choosing Better. The fix is creating clear value separation by withholding the specific capabilities your target buyers need most from the Good tier, while making Better deliver measurably different results rather than just more of the same activity.

Should I let clients pick their tier or recommend one?

Prescribe the tier based on audit findings rather than presenting an open menu. Research shows prescriptive sales approaches increase purchase ease by 86% and reduce sales regret. Run the audit, identify specific gaps like missing DMARC or low mobile performance scores, then recommend the tier that fixes those gaps. Lead with the tier the audit supports, cover the starter quickly, spend most time on the middle tier, and mention enterprise as an aside. This shifts the conversation from choosing packages to prescribing the fix their site needs.

Do three-tier packages actually increase conversions?

Yes, agencies offering three rate options are twice as likely to have conversion rates above 60% according to The Wow Company's BenchPress report. The structure works because customers typically avoid the Best tier fearing overpayment, avoid the Good tier fearing they will miss something important, and settle on the Better tier as the reasonable middle option. This happens through anchoring psychology, where the premium tier serves as an expensive reference point that makes your target middle tier appear smartly priced by comparison.